Baf's Guide to the IF Archive

Home
Intro
Options
Recent Reviews
Reviews This Week

Search the Guide

Game Listings
by Title
by Genre
by Rating
by Platform
Other Indices...

Authors/People

Comps/Awards
XYZZY Awards
The IF Comp
Other...

Companies
Infocom
Level 9
Topologika
Adventure Int./
Scott Adams

More...

Game Series

IF-Related Links

Credits/Volunteers



Turn off tables (requires cookies)

Heroine's Mantle

Author:Andy Phillips
Released:2000
Review:

Massive, and massively ambitious, this game combines a sweeping and complex plot with some of the most fiendish puzzles in existence. You are a young woman swept into the role of superheroine, and the game provides enough hair-raising adventures to fill a half-dozen lesser works of IF. There are many, many locations, NPCs, and scenarios; action scenes worthy of a John Woo movie; and utterly ludicrous challenges to overcome.

Speaking of ludicrous, the puzzle design needs quite a lot of work. The superheroine has certain powers, which are rather fun, and which the game allows the player to learn in a fairly effective manner. Not all of the puzzles turn on these powers, however, and others don't use them in obvious ways; there are many, many places where the game requires syntax that might not be obvious and that is non-standard to IF. Likewise, some puzzles are only solvable by a complex sequence of read-the-author's-mind maneuvers.

Finally, some people may have mixed reactions to the game's treatment of gender -- the overt feminist propaganda sits a bit oddly next to a sometimes voyeuristic treatment of individual women.

In other words, this is a game with higher highs and lower lows than most; where it's good, it's great, and where it's bad, it's terrible. On the whole it comes out worth playing -- set aside a few weeks for the task, because it is not a small game -- but have the solution handy. Some of these puzzles are just not going to make sense any other way.

Rating: ****

Reviewed by Emily Short (01 Jun 2003)

Competitions/
Awards:
Finalist, Best Story, Xyzzy Awards 2000
Finalist, Best Puzzles, Xyzzy Awards 2000
Finalist, Best NPCs, Xyzzy Awards 2000
Related Links:IF-Review
IFRC Review
SPAG review
Downloads:
Heroine.z8 (511.50 KB)
Z-code 8 executable (version: 3)
Heroine.sol (22.41 KB)
solution


Baf's Guide to the Interactive Fiction Archive
Copyright © 2012 Carl Muckenhoupt
All reviews included in this site are copyright © the credited author of the review.